Pork back ribs vs side ribs … the debate rages on.

Greetings Carnivores,

You know, … I’ve been thinking about this post for a very long time now because it’s one of the ALL TIME biggest questions I get asked. At the end of the day … this is just my opinion so, … here we go.

Which is better???

The Pork side rib??? The Pork back rib??? Aka: “Baby back ribs” … which, incidentally is BULLSHIT, because … they do NOT come from “baby” or “immature” animals.

Please excuse my language but, there … I said it !!!

I, personally have ALWAYS preferred the humble side rib because of its “bang for the buck” (how can you argue with the price difference between the two ???) AND, … I don’t care who in the “industry” may or may not take exception to my stance.

The industry WANTS you to believe these so called “baby backs” are a “premium” quality because of their “youthful description” but … it’s nothing more than a straight up, blatant, balls to the wall, CASH GRAB!! As far as I’m concerned, … the side rib is, and always has been, superior to the back and here’s why.

0021101900000_A
“Baby” back ribs.

The back rib is cut from the loin section of the hog. Imagine the whole, bone-in loin. Once the bones are separated from the meat, this now becomes two separate cuts … the boneless loin, and the back rib. Although I love a good loin pork chop, let’s be honest … they can be dry. Well guess what??? This is the same lean meat on the back rib. Dry, dry, dry.

C.C Jan.10 2913 028
St. Louis cut Side rib (bottom) Breast/Sternum portion (top)

The side rib by comparison, is cut from the belly and because of this location on the carcass, much fattier.

EEEWWWWWW you say?? Nope … AWESOME, I say !!

It’s BECAUSE of all this fat that the low and slow cooking process renders them soooooooo DELICIOUS! Now, a LOT of retailers sell the side rib with the “breast/sternum” portion included in the package and, it’s THIS reason a lot of folks don’t like them.

I’ll admit, … there’s a greater proportion of bone and cartilage to meat but … if that’s a problem for you, simply buy the “St Louis” cut side ribs. They are sold without the “breast/sternum” included. They’re a little more money but, WELL worth it in my opinion.

Back to the so-called “Baby” back rib. This portion has been marketed in such a way that YOU, the consumers are lead to believe it’s BETTER and, … I’m here to tell you today … it … is … NOT!!

Let’s be truthful folks … these cuts (both back and side) are NOT tender cuts. They both need a LOT of TLC and to be rubbed, massaged, and cooked over low and slow heat for extended periods of time. The problem I have with Back ribs is their “location” on the carcass. As I said before, they come from the loin section and as such, the meat on them is SOOOOO MUCH LEANER.

“Awesome” you say … and, I say “Nay, Nay”

The MUCH leaner meat on the Back rib is SOOOOOOO MUCH DRIER!!

Ok, … I’m not sure if I have many believers here so … just do yourselves a favour … and do a side by side comparison of the two … be fair, spice them the same way, cook them the same way, and PLEASE, let me know in the comments section below.

Fair enough??

That’s it for today Carnivores 🙂 🙂

Thanks for dropping in … Oh, and by the way … you can share this post with your peeps by following my Blog … otherwise, just scroll down to the “share” area below and “click” on any of the buttons and … share away!!  🙂 🙂

Please, stay tuned and … please click “follow” on this page (Carnivore Confidential). You’ll get an email notice every time I write something new. And, … no need to worry about being bombarded with junk … WordPress is VERY responsible.  🙂

Until next time Carnivores, stay hungry and as usual, please like and share my posts on Facebook http://www.facebook.com/carnivoreconfidential

And, follow on Twitter @DougieDee

Responses

  1. Tasty Eats Ronit Penso Avatar

    Thank you, I’ve learned something new. Though I don’t recall seeing the “St Louis” cut side ribs anywhere, but now I’ll specifically look for it.

    1. Carnivore Confidential Avatar

      Good hunting, good eating and, thanks for stopping by 🙂

  2. Rémi Bérubé Avatar

    Hi, Here is my humble opinion,: Even if the back ribs were cheaper the bones being heavier, the difference in the price per pound might not be too much for enjoying a better product

    1. Carnivore Confidential Avatar

      Like I said Remi … just my opinion but … I STILL love the humble side rib. Thanks for dropping in 🙂

      1. Rémi Bérubé Avatar

        My english being what it is (not the best) i really meant that side ribs, even if it looked like they’re more expensive, were worth the extra few cents per pound for a better product 🙂 Thanks for sharing your knowledge with us. Have a nice evening.

  3. simon Avatar

    Agree with all most everything you write here, apart from those baby back are far more tender, you can you dust them and directly cook them, ok there is a slight bite, you couldn’t do it with belly ribs.

    1. Carnivore Confidential Avatar

      Thanks for dropping by Simon 🙂

  4. Gary Avatar

    Thanks, Doug for the detailed explanation of the difference between side and back ribs.

    1. Carnivore Confidential Avatar

      Any time Dr. Gary. Stay warm down under friend 🙂

      1. Gary Avatar

        I’m trying Doug. Having the oven on for four hours yesterday helped 😃

  5. Liz Avatar

    My local Food Basic is selling tons and tons of baby back ribs. I just didn’t like the way they were packed in huge chunks and there was nothing ‘baby’ and tender about them. Now I know why!!!

    1. Carnivore Confidential Avatar

      Thanks for dropping by Liz … I loved your post re: the Picnic Shoulder. That topic is on my radar for a future post and, when I write it, I’ll “ping back” to yours. Have a GREAT day !!!

  6. Andrew Avatar

    Gotta agree Doug.
    I always buy back ribs but this weekend saw spare ribs on sale…$1.99/lb.
    Couldn’t resist as for the first time in forever I didn’t have any ribs in the freezer.
    Did them low and slow in the oven, covered with foil on a rack over some water for 2.5hrs.
    30 minutes at 350F, 2hrs at 250.
    Remove and slather on some sauce.
    Broil until caramelized or bake at 450 for the same effect.
    Absolutely fan freaking tastic.
    I’m a convert.

    1. Carnivore Confidential Avatar

      o glad you liked them … I couldn’t agree more

Leave a comment